How Can I Make `.innertext` Ignore Invisible Children Of An Invisible Element?

Result of the test code below: div[0].innerText === 'aaaaa zzzzz' div[1].innerText === '␤aaaaa␤invisible␤zzzzz␤' How can I force innerText to give the same result for div[

Solution 1:

Only appending it to a document literally visible to the user works.

But the user doesn't necessarily have to see that. :-) If you append it, grab innerText, and then remove it, the user will never see it:

var div = [];
div[0] = document.getElementById("visible");
div[1] = div[0].cloneNode(true);

show(0);
document.body.appendChild(div[1]);  // *****show(1);
document.body.removeChild(div[1]);  // *****functionshow(i) {
    document.getElementById("output").innerHTML += 
      "<p>div[" + i + "].innerText === <code>" + 
      div[i].innerText.replace(/\n/g, "␤") + "</code></p>";
}

#visible {display: block; font-family: sans-serif; font-size: larger; color: red;}
code {background-color: lightgray; padding: 0 .318em;}

<divid="visible"><spanstyle="display: inline">aaaaa</span><spanstyle="display: none">invisible</span><spanstyle="display: inline">zzzzz</span></div><divid="output"></p>

Alternately, since the element isn't in the DOM, it can't be made invisible by CSS, only inline styles. I can't think of any other inline style that would make the text get left out of innerText other than your display: none and visibility: hidden (opacity: 0, for instance, doesn't do it), so it's trivial to exclude those and normalize whitespace for non-pre elements:

functiongetInnerText(element) {
  var node, text = "";
  if (element.style.display.toLowerCase() !== "none" && element.style.visibility.toLowerCase() !== "hidden") {
    for (node = element.firstChild; node; node = node.nextSibling) {
      if (node.nodeType === 3) {
        text += node.nodeValue;
      } elseif (node.nodeType === 1) {
        text += getInnerText(node);
      }
    }
  }
  // Normalize all whitespace if not "pre"if (element.tagName !== "PRE" && element.style.whiteSpace.toLowerCase().indexOf("pre") == -1) {
    text = text.replace(/\s+/g, ' ');
  }
  return text;
}

That may well need tweaking (I don't think it handles <div>stuff<pre>big gap</pre></div> properly), but you can run with the idea if you don't want to use the first solution above...

Example:

var div = [];
div[0] = document.getElementById("visible");
div[1] = div[0].cloneNode(true);

show(0);
document.body.appendChild(div[1]);  // *****show(1);
document.body.removeChild(div[1]);  // *****functionshow(i) {
    document.getElementById("output").innerHTML += 
      "<p>div[" + i + "].innerText === <code>" + 
      getInnerText(div[i]).replace(/\n/g, "␤") + "</code></p>";
}

functiongetInnerText(element) {
  var node, text = "";
  if (element.style.display.toLowerCase() !== "none" && element.style.visibility.toLowerCase() !== "hidden") {
    for (node = element.firstChild; node; node = node.nextSibling) {
      if (node.nodeType === 3) {
        text += node.nodeValue;
      } elseif (node.nodeType === 1) {
        text += getInnerText(node);
      }
    }
  }
  // Normalize all whitespace if not "pre"if (element.tagName !== "PRE" && element.style.whiteSpace.toLowerCase().indexOf("pre") == -1) {
    text = text.replace(/\s+/g, " ");
  }
  return text;
}

#visible {display: block; font-family: sans-serif; font-size: larger; color: red;}
code {background-color: lightgray; padding: 0 .318em;}

<divid="visible"><spanstyle="display: inline">aaaaa</span><spanstyle="display: none">invisible</span><spanstyle="display: inline">zzzzz</span></div><divid="output"></p>